New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani is drawing criticism for his handling of a Jan. 26 incident in Queens involving a mentally ill man who was shot by NYPD officers after allegedly charging at them with a large kitchen knife.
According to police, NYPD officers responding to a domestic disturbance call repeatedly ordered the 22‑year‑old suspect, identified as Jabez Chakraborty, to drop the weapon. When he continued advancing, an officer fired multiple shots, leaving him in critical condition at a local hospital.
Mamdani publicly urged the Queens district attorney not to prosecute Chakraborty, arguing that the man needs mental health treatment rather than criminal charges — a position that has drawn opposition from law enforcement advocates and some members of the public.
At a news conference, the mayor said the incident highlights a need for broader crisis response options involving behavioral health professionals, noting that police should not always be the default responders in mental health emergencies.
Criticism for hospital visit and priorities
Critics — particularly on social media — have reacted strongly to posts and secondary commentary alleging that Mamdani visited the wounded suspect in the hospital but did not make a similar gesture toward the NYPD officer involved in the shooting. These critiques have circulated widely on Reddit and other forums, though mainstream outlets have not confirmed the specific claim about whom the mayor visited.
Supporters of Mamdani argue his actions reflect concern for mental health advocacy and reform of crisis response protocols, not disregard for law enforcement. Opponents contend his stance risks undermining public safety and sends the wrong message about accountability after violent confrontations.
Ongoing debate
The Queens district attorney’s office is still investigating the case and has not yet announced whether charges will be filed related to the attack on officers.
